Really enjoyed it for a while! I'm excited to see it develop—seems like a lot of the complaints in the comment section have already been resolved! personally I'd love some resource management elements, like maybe you have to use resources to complete skill checks, so if you're out of a resource you might have to use a less advantageous skill. could give the player some more impetus for leveling up the boat if that's something you're thinking of adding too. either way, good luck and i'll look forward to updates!
first impression was really good. nice artwork. i was confused where my crew ended up after the first expedition until i realized that i have to remember the names and recruit them again. the events are a bit random so there is not too much that keeps one wanting to explore more. but there is certainly potential there.
Hi dzambhala, thanks for commenting, I'm working on a new version that addresses most of the issues mentioned, and adds a lot of depth to the game (relics to be discovered and collected, crew upgrade options, etc). If you're interested, consider following the project 😊
It's just too random There's no reliable answer yet skills dont seem to affect it that much, a minor case of insomnia kills your crew, there's no 'winning', and if answers change but your stats can't brute force the wrong option then you will always lose good crew and are blocked further from progressing
It seems like an interesting story don't get me wrong, but it's a good story, not so much the game part of it, how we interact with that story
Could still stay along the same vein of what's already here if you wanted, but it needs some adjustment
Hi PJO, thanks for the review. It does indeed lack a lot of player control over the outcome.
I'm planning some changes in this regard, such as allowing the player to choose which sailors to risk in a challenge, displaying the win percentage for each challenge, and adding more player input to the story.
Thanks again for the review. If you could test it again in the future after the changes are made and leave a review, I'd really appreciate it!
I love the art here - the style is simple and everything is clear and understandable.
That being said, I think the struggle I'm having with it is that I feel like I'm making blind decisions. When I only have 2 options to choose from and it's not guaranteed that my stats will lead to a positive outcome, I feel like my decisions don't carry as much weight as I think the game wants them to have. I ended up losing my level 3 explorer to said 50/50 random outcome and it left a bitter taste in my mouth.
Given, these style of games are not the kind of games I gravitate towards, so it could very well be that this game isn't for me. And that's okay :)
I agree with your points, currently the stats carry some weight in the final result of the challenges, but this weight still leaves room for a lot of randomness.
I'm planning some changes that should improve this aspect, since I loved working on this project and I believe there is a lot of room for improvement!
Once again, thank you very much for taking the time to play and leave your opinion!
I am not sure if my crew selection had much of an impact on any of the outcomes. They seemed to be quite random. I am assuming there is some kind of minimum value required for a successful encounter. The ability to get permanent upgrades would have helped.
okay, I dont get this game. Like sure, I get how to play it. but it feels like I just choose the 3 guys with the best stats, sent them ashore (in my case also was to the "La Isleta...").and pray that none die.when choosing options, always choosing the one option corresponding to the higher team stat. none the less my level 4guy jsut died in the last journey and I am back to level 1 guy -.- dont really see how to improve here, as I jsut keep throwing newbie in there, hoping thta one might survive a few journeys before dying.
← Return to game
Comments
Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.
Really enjoyed it for a while! I'm excited to see it develop—seems like a lot of the complaints in the comment section have already been resolved! personally I'd love some resource management elements, like maybe you have to use resources to complete skill checks, so if you're out of a resource you might have to use a less advantageous skill. could give the player some more impetus for leveling up the boat if that's something you're thinking of adding too. either way, good luck and i'll look forward to updates!
first impression was really good. nice artwork. i was confused where my crew ended up after the first expedition until i realized that i have to remember the names and recruit them again. the events are a bit random so there is not too much that keeps one wanting to explore more. but there is certainly potential there.
Hi dzambhala, thanks for commenting, I'm working on a new version that addresses most of the issues mentioned, and adds a lot of depth to the game (relics to be discovered and collected, crew upgrade options, etc). If you're interested, consider following the project 😊
It's just too random
There's no reliable answer yet skills dont seem to affect it that much, a minor case of insomnia kills your crew, there's no 'winning', and if answers change but your stats can't brute force the wrong option then you will always lose good crew and are blocked further from progressing
It seems like an interesting story don't get me wrong, but it's a good story, not so much the game part of it, how we interact with that story
Could still stay along the same vein of what's already here if you wanted, but it needs some adjustment
Hi PJO, thanks for the review. It does indeed lack a lot of player control over the outcome.
I'm planning some changes in this regard, such as allowing the player to choose which sailors to risk in a challenge, displaying the win percentage for each challenge, and adding more player input to the story.
Thanks again for the review. If you could test it again in the future after the changes are made and leave a review, I'd really appreciate it!
maybe there should be resources gathered by the boat.
and those can unlock bigger boats or something.
bigger boats, longer trips, more events, hospital for crew. etc ;)
then creating a good crew would make sense.
These are some really cool ideas! Some of them are in development, like ship upgrades, allowing for larger crews and expeditions!
Thanks for playing and leaving your feedback!
I love the art here - the style is simple and everything is clear and understandable.
That being said, I think the struggle I'm having with it is that I feel like I'm making blind decisions. When I only have 2 options to choose from and it's not guaranteed that my stats will lead to a positive outcome, I feel like my decisions don't carry as much weight as I think the game wants them to have. I ended up losing my level 3 explorer to said 50/50 random outcome and it left a bitter taste in my mouth.
Given, these style of games are not the kind of games I gravitate towards, so it could very well be that this game isn't for me. And that's okay :)
Thanks for playing, Crimson!
I agree with your points, currently the stats carry some weight in the final result of the challenges, but this weight still leaves room for a lot of randomness.
I'm planning some changes that should improve this aspect, since I loved working on this project and I believe there is a lot of room for improvement!
Once again, thank you very much for taking the time to play and leave your opinion!
I am not sure if my crew selection had much of an impact on any of the outcomes. They seemed to be quite random. I am assuming there is some kind of minimum value required for a successful encounter. The ability to get permanent upgrades would have helped.
The art and audio are great.
okay, I dont get this game.
Like sure, I get how to play it.
but it feels like I just choose the 3 guys with the best stats, sent them ashore (in my case also was to the "La Isleta...").and pray that none die.when choosing options, always choosing the one option corresponding to the higher team stat.
none the less my level 4guy jsut died in the last journey and I am back to level 1 guy -.-
dont really see how to improve here, as I jsut keep throwing newbie in there, hoping thta one might survive a few journeys before dying.